How to Choose Between an Employee, Contractor, or Firm for Your Bookkeeping Needs

How to Choose Between an Employee, Contractor, or Firm for Your Bookkeeping Needs 1

How to Choose Between an Employee, Contractor, or Firm for Your Bookkeeping Needs

Key Points

Choosing the right type of bookkeeping service is important for any business, regardless of its size or industry. Bookkeeping forms the backbone of your financial management, impacting everything from daily operations to long-term strategic planning. Whether you’re a small startup navigating the early stages of growth or an established company aiming to optimize efficiency, the decision to hire an employee, contractor, or firm for your bookkeeping needs can have significant consequences. Each option comes with its own set of advantages and challenges, and understanding these can help you make the best choice for your business.

In this blog, we’ll delve into the specifics of hiring an in-house employee, a freelance contractor, and a professional bookkeeping firm.

Understanding Your Options

When it comes to managing your business’s financial records, you have three primary options: hiring an in-house employee, engaging a freelance contractor, or partnering with a professional bookkeeping firm. Each of these options offers unique benefits and challenges that can affect your financial management and overall business operations. Understanding these differences is essential for making an informed decision that aligns with your business goals and resources. Whether you need consistent on-site support, flexible part-time assistance, or comprehensive and expert-level financial services, evaluating your options thoroughly will help ensure you choose the right solution for your bookkeeping needs.

Let’s explore each option thoroughly to help you determine which is best suited for your specific bookkeeping needs, whether you require consistent on-site support, flexible part-time assistance, or comprehensive and expert-level financial services.

Employee Bookkeepers

An employee bookkeeper is someone you hire as part of your internal team. They work full-time or part-time and handle all your bookkeeping tasks in-house.


– Consistency: Having a dedicated person ensures consistency in managing your books. This can be particularly beneficial for businesses with complex financial operations that require constant monitoring and updates.

– Immediate Access: You have direct access to your bookkeeper whenever needed. This can expedite decision-making processes and allow for quick resolution of any financial discrepancies.

– Familiarity: An employee will become familiar with your business’s financial intricacies over time. This intimate knowledge can lead to more accurate and tailored financial management.


– Costly: Full-time employees require salaries, benefits, and training. These costs can add up, especially for small businesses with limited budgets.

– Space and Resources: You need to provide office space and resources. This can be a significant overhead expense, particularly in high-rent areas like New York or San Francisco.

– Turnover Risk: If your bookkeeper leaves, it can disrupt your operations. Finding and training a replacement can be time-consuming and costly.

Contractor Bookkeepers

Contractors are independent professionals you hire on a temporary or project basis. They are not full-time employees but work for you as needed.


– Flexibility: You can hire contractors for specific tasks or busy periods. This is particularly useful for businesses with fluctuating bookkeeping needs.

– Cost-Efficient: No need to pay benefits or provide office space. You only pay for the work done, which can lead to significant cost savings.

– Specialized Skills: Contractors often bring specialized expertise. They can handle complex bookkeeping tasks that might be beyond the skill set of a general in-house bookkeeper.


– Availability: Contractors may not always be available when you need them. Their schedules can be unpredictable, especially if they are juggling multiple clients.

– Less Integration: They might not be as familiar with your business as an in-house employee. This can lead to a learning curve and potential inefficiencies.

– Quality Variability: The quality of work can vary depending on the contractor. It’s essential to thoroughly vet any contractor you consider hiring.

Bookkeeping Firms

Bookkeeping firms are companies that offer comprehensive bookkeeping services. They employ a team of professionals who manage your books remotely or on-site.


– Expertise: Firms provide access to a team of experienced bookkeepers. This collective knowledge can be invaluable, particularly for businesses with complex financial needs.

– Scalability: Easy to scale services up or down based on your needs. Whether you’re growing rapidly or facing a downturn, firms can adjust their level of service accordingly.

– Reliability: Firms have systems in place to ensure continuity and quality. This means you won’t have to worry about disruptions due to employee turnover or absences.


– Cost: Can be more expensive than hiring a contractor but often more reliable. The higher cost can be justified by the comprehensive services and expertise provided.

– Less Personal: May not offer the same level of personal attention as an in-house employee. The relationship might feel more transactional.

– Communication: Might require more effort to maintain clear communication. Effective communication channels are crucial to ensure your financial needs are met accurately and timely.

Factors to Consider Before Hiring Someone for your Bookkeeping Needs

When choosing between an employee, contractor, or firm for your bookkeeping needs, it’s important to consider various factors such as cost, expertise, flexibility, and scalability. Each option has its own set of advantages and limitations that can influence your decision based on your business’s specific requirements and long-term goals.


Employee: Consider the total cost including salary, benefits, and office expenses. For many businesses, the all-in cost of an employee can be prohibitively high.

Contractor: Pay for the work done, no additional costs. This can be a more budget-friendly option for businesses with limited bookkeeping needs.

Firm: Generally higher rates, but you get a team of experts. The investment in a firm can be worth it for the quality and breadth of services provided.


Employee: Can develop deep knowledge of your business but may lack broader expertise. Continuous training might be necessary to keep them updated with the latest bookkeeping practices.

Contractor: Offers specialized skills but might lack comprehensive understanding of your business. It’s important to ensure the contractor’s skills align with your specific bookkeeping needs.

Firm: Provides a wide range of expertise from a team of professionals. This can be particularly beneficial for businesses with diverse and complex financial operations.


Employee: Fixed hours and availability. This can be a limitation if your business has fluctuating bookkeeping needs.

Contractor: Flexible hours and availability. Contractors can be hired on an as-needed basis, providing greater flexibility.

Firm: Highly scalable, can adjust services as your business grows. Firms can easily ramp up or down their services to match your business’s needs.


Employee: Dependable but at risk of turnover. Employee absences or turnover can disrupt your bookkeeping processes.

Contractor: Reliable for specific tasks but may not be consistently available. It’s essential to have a backup plan if your primary contractor is unavailable.

Firm: Highly reliable with structured systems in place. Firms have established processes and multiple team members to ensure continuity of service.

Business Size

Employee: Best for small to medium-sized businesses with steady bookkeeping needs. An in-house bookkeeper can be a good fit if your bookkeeping needs are consistent and manageable.

Contractor: Suitable for small businesses or startups with occasional needs. Contractors can provide the necessary support without the long-term commitment of an employee.

Firm: Ideal for medium to large businesses requiring extensive and ongoing bookkeeping support. Firms are well-equipped to handle the complex and evolving needs of larger businesses.

Making the Right Choice

When deciding between an employee, contractor, or firm, consider your business size, budget, and specific bookkeeping needs. Think about the level of expertise required and the importance of having someone familiar with your business’s financial details.

For instance:

– Small businesses might benefit from the flexibility and cost savings of hiring a contractor. Contractors can provide the necessary support without long-term commitment.

– Medium-sized businesses could find value in a dedicated employee who understands their operations intimately. An employee can offer consistency and immediate access to financial insights.

– Large businesses or those experiencing rapid growth may prefer the scalability and reliability of a bookkeeping firm. Firms can provide comprehensive services and handle the increased complexity of larger operations.

Finding the Ideal Bookkeeping Partner

Choosing the right bookkeeping solution is a critical decision for your business’s financial health. Evaluate your needs carefully, consider the pros and cons of each option, and select the one that aligns best with your business goals. Effective bookkeeping is essential for smooth and efficient business operations, whether you choose an employee, contractor, or firm.

Partnering with firms like YourLegal for your bookkeeping needs can provide you with the expertise and flexibility you require. Our team is ready to help you navigate the complexities of your financial management, ensuring your business stays on the path to success. By understanding your unique needs and offering tailored solutions, we aim to support your business growth and scalability, providing peace of mind and reliable financial management.

Follow us on Instagram